Karstedt's catalyst or peroxide cure: the real trade-offs
Why medical and food-contact silicone moved to addition cure, and where peroxide still wins on cost and tolerance.
Peroxide cure and addition cure both produce silicone rubber, and the choice between them is usually presented as a cost question. It is better understood as a by-product question. Peroxide systems break down during cure and leave fragments behind; platinum-catalysed addition systems cross-link by hydrosilylation and release no by-products. That single difference decides which chemistry is acceptable for a given end use, before price is considered.
What each chemistry actually does
A peroxide cure relies on heat to decompose an organic peroxide into radicals, which then abstract hydrogen from the silicone chains and form cross-links. The reaction is robust and largely indifferent to the filler, but the decomposition products remain in the part and continue to evolve after moulding. An addition cure uses a platinum complex to add silicon–hydrogen bonds across vinyl groups. The reaction produces no small-molecule by-products, and the cure can be held back with an inhibitor until the compound reaches temperature.
By-products decide the application
Volatile fragments from peroxide decomposition are the reason medical, food-contact and optical silicone moved to addition cure. They can fog an optical surface, affect taste and odour, and fail an incoming VOC specification even when the mechanical properties are acceptable. A post-cure oven can drive off part of the residue, but it adds a process step and does not remove the chemistry. For a transparent part judged on clarity, the difference is visible.
Where each system still wins
Peroxide cure retains a real place in formulations where colour and volatiles are not part of the specification, while addition cure is the default wherever by-products are unacceptable. The split is usually obvious once the end use is stated.
Peroxide cure still fits
- Thick, heavily filled parts where colour and volatile emissions are not part of the specification.
- Formulations that must tolerate contaminants or fillers that would poison a platinum catalyst.
- Low-cost industrial parts where the total cost of the addition-cure route cannot be justified.
- Processes already validated around a peroxide line, where a chemistry change would trigger a full re-qualification.
Addition cure is the default
- Transparent and optical parts, including PPF top coats and light-guide components.
- Medical devices and food-contact articles, where by-products are unacceptable.
- Release liners and precision coatings, where cure speed and surface quality are measured.
- Potting and encapsulation, where a controlled cure window and stable electrical properties matter.
The comparison that matters
The table below is the short version. The numbers that decide the choice are not on the catalyst data sheet; they are the costs of rejects, post-cure, ventilation and re-qualification.
| Criterion | Peroxide cure | Addition cure |
|---|---|---|
| Cure mechanism | Free-radical decomposition | Platinum-catalysed hydrosilylation |
| By-products | Organic fragments remain in the part | None; VOC-free cross-linking |
| Colour and clarity | Can yellow or haze; post-cure needed | Optical clarity achievable with the right grade |
| Contaminant tolerance | High | Sensitive to sulfur, phosphorus, nitrogen and heavy metals |
| Working time control | Limited; scorch risk on hot lines | Inhibitor sets pot life without slowing the hot cure |
| Medical and food contact | By-products fail most reviews | The standard route |
Cost beyond the price per kilogram
A peroxide system usually has the lower raw-material price. The comparison changes when the full process is counted: post-cure energy and time, extraction or ventilation, odour control, and the rejects caused by fogging or colour shift. On the addition-cure side the costs are different — a platinum catalyst, a matched inhibitor, and the discipline needed to keep poisons out of the compound. Where yield and appearance are specified, the addition route often wins on total cost even though it loses on the drum price.
The risk on the addition side is process sensitivity. A sulfur-cured glove, a release agent or a recycled filler can stop the cure entirely. That is a management problem as much as a chemistry problem: the line has to be protected from contaminants, and the catalyst grade has to match the environment. High-activity and anti-poisoning grades exist for exactly that reason.
Compare the cured part: yield, post-cure steps, energy, rejects and re-qualification. The chemistry with the cheaper catalyst is not always the cheaper part.
For a formulation moving from peroxide to addition cure, the first trial should pair a standard grade such as PC-12 with an inhibitor matched to the cure temperature, and include a control made with the existing peroxide system. PC-42 is the choice when colour after heat exposure is part of the specification.
The grades behind this article.
5,000 PPM
The high-concentration workhorse. 5,000 PPM delivers fast cross-linking for lines that need short cycle times, and it is the grade most often specified for injection and rapid-cure processes.
5,000 PPM
The anti-yellowing benchmark. Under 85°C / 48 h accelerated aging, PC-42 holds ΔE 0.8 against 4.2 for a conventional Karstedt's catalyst. Specified into premium PPF top coats, optical films and any coating judged by colour after heat exposure.
Match the article to your formulation.
Send the process window, get a pairing recommendation.
Cure temperature, line speed, section thickness and the pot life you need are enough for a first recommendation on grade, concentration and inhibitor dosage.
Continue with the next question.
Each of these articles covers one part of the same curing system: concentration, inhibition, contamination and documentation.
Why is my silicone rubber not curing? Six root causes
Before you add more catalyst, rule out the six causes that account for most addition-cure failures — from poisoning to mixing order.
Platinum catalyst PPM: how to choose between 1,000 and 20,000
Concentration is not a quality grade. A practical way to select PPM from line speed, section thickness and inhibitor dosage.
How to extend silicone pot life without slowing the cure
The inhibitor is the control knob for working time. How dosage, type and temperature interact, with a starting matrix.
From article to evaluation sample
If this article describes your process, request a sample of the recommended grade with the matching inhibitor. Evaluation quantities ship in 5–7 days.